PIE 2 PIE - A Pizza Maker’s Podcast
Pie 2 Pie is a podcast serving up candid conversations with pizza shop owners giving listeners an insider perspective on the real-life highs & lows of entrepreneurship and running a pizzeria.
Listen on:
Episodes
Friday Oct 03, 2025
Friday Oct 03, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
Friday Sep 26, 2025
Friday Sep 26, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
Friday Sep 19, 2025
Friday Sep 19, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
Friday Sep 12, 2025
Friday Sep 12, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
World Pizza Champion, Leah Scurto joins Pie2Pie to share her incredible journey from college dropout to 22-year Pizza My Heart veteran to opening her own award-winning pizzeria, PizzaLeah, in Sonoma County. We discuss the realities of restaurant ownership, the importance of paying staff well, competing in Italy, teaching at Pizza University, and why she believes your employees just want to get paid at the end of the day. Plus stories about the wild '90s pizza scene, third-party delivery drivers, and why she's sworn off tequila.
Friday Sep 05, 2025
Friday Sep 05, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
On this episode of Pie2Pie, we sit down with Mike Hauke, the creative force behind Tony Boloney's pizza shops and the innovative Mad Mutz mozzarella stick company. Fresh off his successful Shark Tank appearance where he landed a deal with Lori Greiner, Mike shares his entrepreneurial journey from restaurant owner to food manufacturer.
Friday Aug 29, 2025
Friday Aug 29, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🍕 Be in Business for yourself, not by yourself w/ SLICE : https://bit.ly/SLICENOW
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
On this episode, join us at Tony's Baltimore Grill in Atlantic City, a legendary pizza institution approaching its 100th anniversary in 2027. Alex sits down with Joey Palumbo, the manager who's been running this iconic spot for the past four years, to explore what makes this place so special.
From surviving Atlantic City's ups and downs to maintaining authentic recipes while navigating modern challenges like third-party delivery apps, Joey shares insights into running a restaurant and managing staff who some have been there way longer than he has. The conversation covers everything from stolen patio furniture that became national news to the "Don't Be Ted" roast beef sandwich campaign that turned a negative review into a marketing goldmine.
Discover why Tony's isn't for everyone (and why they're okay with that), hear stories about celebrity visits from Pink to Sinatra, and learn about the delicate balance of preserving tradition while adapting to change. Plus, Joey opens up about his journey from teaching to restaurant management, his pickle business with his son, and why empowering staff to stand up to difficult customers is part of their philosophy.
Chapters:
00:00:00 - Welcome to Tony's
00:01:31 - First Impressions
00:02:57 - Joey's Kitchen Journey
00:04:45 - Managing the Veteran Staff
00:08:25 - Atlantic City Through the Decades
00:12:17 - The Secret to 50-Year Survival
00:16:28 - Pizza Production and Weather Wars
00:20:06 - Stolen Chairs and Viral Fame
00:24:03 - The Customer Isn't Always Right
00:27:17 - Third-Party Delivery Disasters
00:32:05 - Late Night Hours and Characters
00:36:06 - From White House Subs to Teaching
00:42:08 - Eagles Victory and Philly Pride
00:44:16 - Managing 60 Staff Members
00:48:54 - Food vs Booze Balance
00:50:46 - Celebrity Visits and Famous Faces
00:52:23 - Restoring the Original Aesthetic
00:57:33 - Not for Everyone and That's OK
01:00:20 - Generations and Community Fabric
01:02:24 - Accountability and Final Recommendations
Friday Aug 22, 2025
Friday Aug 22, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🍕 Be in Business for yourself, not by yourself w/ SLICE : https://bit.ly/SLICENOW
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
In this raw and inspiring episode, we sit down with Mike Fitzick, owner of Bakeria 1010, a beloved pizzeria and small batch bakery in Ocean City, on the Jersey Shore. This is a story of passion, and the relentless pursuit of pizza perfection. This episode showcases the gritty reality of running a high-quality pizza operation while maintaining work-life balance in a demanding seasonal market. It's a testament to how passion, persistence, and authentic storytelling can build a successful business from the ground up.
Featured Topics: • Detroit-style square pizza technique • Sourdough starter maintenance and fermentation • Seasonal restaurant operations • Instagram marketing for restaurants • Addiction recovery in the food industry • Italian pizza culture vs. American adaptation • Equipment: Gozney ovens, King Arthur flour blends • Shore town business dynamics
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
3:20 75 days straight working - the seasonal grind
7:44 Early pizza career and addiction struggles
16:12 Mike’s recovery journey
20:24 Learning Neapolitan pizza and falling out with partners
24:09 One of the first Gozney influencers in North America
27:11 The pop-up era and building a following
35:15 Smuggling sourdough starter from Naples
42:17 The science of square pizza dough and hydration
58:00 Organic flour and the weevil problem
1:03:16 The neighbor pizzeria situation
1:17:02 Customer education and the Jersey Shore pizza scene
Friday Aug 15, 2025
Friday Aug 15, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🍕 Be in Business for yourself, not by yourself w/ SLICE : https://bit.ly/SLICENOW
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
Odie O'Connor is rewriting the playbook on pizza business ownership. From slinging pies out of a Portland food cart to running Boxcar Pizza remotely while launching a brand-new concept 1,000 miles away, Odie proves there's no single "right" way to build success in this industry. In this episode, we dive into his journey from Baby Blue Pizza to Boxcar to his latest venture, Odie's Pizza Co. in Oceanside — a space four times bigger with four times the staff. We talk about the natural progression of stepping stones, why he hired a general manager from day one, the art of running a business remotely, and how good partnerships make all the difference.
Friday Aug 08, 2025
Friday Aug 08, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🍕 Be in Business for yourself, not by yourself w/ SLICE : https://bit.ly/SLICENOW
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
On this episode, we are in Portland Oregon to chat with Scott Rivera of Scottie's Pizza Parlor. Scott's shop is easily one of the greatest pizza shops to emerge in the last 20 years. If you've ever picked up a Pizza Today, chances are you've seen his pizza—his slices might have graced more pages than Tony G himself. Scottie's pizza is in a league of its own. This pizzeria's process is constantly evolving, never afraid to break the rules if it means making better pizza or building a better shop. From pioneering PizzaMaster ovens in Portland to developing his signature double-bake method and revolutionary screen technique, Scott has influenced pizza makers and pizzeria owners nationwide. I've admired this pizza maker for years, not just for his pizza brilliance, but for how he leads his pizzeria. He offers healthcare, paid vacations, and includes a 20% charge on every order to make sure his team earns a real living wage. He's always put people before profit, and it shows. This trip was all about closing things out with Scott and man, the conversation did not disappoint. We dive deep into his pizza innovations, the controversial Caputo Cup win, the franchise offer he turned down, and what it really takes to perfect an 18-inch sourdough pizza slice using a PizzaMaster oven. We could've talked for two more hours if the pizzeria didn't have to open.
Friday Aug 01, 2025
Friday Aug 01, 2025
This Episode’s Sponsors→
🍕 Be in Business for yourself, not by yourself w/ SLICE : https://bit.ly/SLICENOW
🌶️ Join The Pepper Flake Revolution: https://bit.ly/flatironpepper
🎶 Maestro Sausage: https://bit.ly/maestro-sausage
Get a NEW GOZNEY: https://us.gozney.com/?dt_id=1529737
Here's some FREE stuff →
🚀HOW TO STEAL A RECIPE https://www.subscribepage.com/howtostealarecipe
🍕 Thinking of Opening a Pizza Shop? Start here: https://howtoopenapizzashop.com/
My Amazon Storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/alexkoons
On this episode, we talk to Justin from Pretty Boy Pizza. He’d just opened his doors at Little Beast Brewing when we rolled through Portland, but already collecting hard-earned lessons. It’s always wild to hear how people stumble into the pizza biz, and Justin’s story involves living a hundred unfinished lives - military service, following love to San Diego, grinding at Blaze Pizza, learning under legends like Odie and Scott Rivera. From getting scammed with 100 pounds of literal trash instead of a mixer to walk-in coolers dying mid-service, Justin’s first three weeks have been beautifully chaotic. But one thing feels certain: his square pizzas are about to become a Portland staple. It’s a ride through living, laughing, loving, and learning.
Key ingredients: • Opening a pizza shop with minimal equipment and budget • Working in shared kitchen spaces and brewery partnerships • Scaling production from pop-ups to brick-and-mortar • Equipment failures and supply chain disasters (what to expect) • Staffing challenges and labor management in early days • Detroit vs. Sicilian vs. grandma style pizza debate • Working with convection ovens for square pies • Building systems and consistency from day one • Learning from pizza industry mentors and legends • Social media marketing and brand building for new restaurants • Managing sell-outs and customer expectations • Restaurant POS systems and financial tracking